News Articles

Main Content

Thumbs Up, Thumbs Down: Formative Assessment on the Fly

When I taught high school Geometry, I had a sophisticated assessment tool that required no technology, no preparation, and absolutely no budget. I asked my students to give me a thumbs-up, thumbs-down, or thumbs-sideways.

Thumbs-up: I’ve got it.

Thumbs-sideways: I think I’ve got it, but please don’t ask me to explain it.

Thumbs-down: You lost me about three slides ago.

Sometimes I used a five-finger scale. Five fingers meant they were ready to teach the lesson themselves. One lonely thumb meant we had some more work to do.

Was it scientific? Not particularly. Did it give me useful information? Absolutely. That’s formative assessment in a nutshell. It’s simply checking to see what students understand while there’s still time to do something about it.

Try pausing during your next lecture and asking students to rate their understanding. Give them a brief clinical scenario and ask what they think happens next. Pose a multiple-choice question and have them hold up the number of fingers corresponding to their answer. Or ask them to identify the “muddiest point” from the last 15 minutes.

Of course, a room full of raised thumbs doesn’t necessarily mean everyone understands. Students sometimes overestimate what they know, and nobody particularly enjoys announcing to 165 classmates that they’re completely lost. That’s why it’s important to occasionally ask students to show what they know, rather than simply tell you how confident they feel.

One easy way is retrieval practice. Instead of asking, “Remember what we discussed 20 minutes ago?” ask students to recall it without looking at their notes. Research shows that retrieving information from memory can actually strengthen learning (Trumble et al., 2024).

But here’s the important part: Do something with the information you get.

If half the room gives you a sideways thumb, don’t just smile and advance to the next slide! Try another explanation, give a different example, or let students talk through the concept with a neighbor. Sometimes a small adjustment makes all the difference.

Formative assessment isn’t about proving that teaching happened. It’s about finding out whether learning is happening. So, during your next lecture, take 30 seconds to find out where your students are. No quiz. No gradebook. No elaborate presentation.

Sometimes all it takes is a thumb.

Reference

Trumble, E., Lodge, J., Mandrusiak, A., & Forbes, R. (2024). Systematic review of distributed practice and retrieval practice in health professions education. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 29(2), 689-714. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-023-10274-3